Black Rock Coffee Kept Most of Its Shops Open Later. The Evening Shift Paid Off
The drive-thru coffee war now runs past 8 p.m. Black Rock is selling later hours while Dutch Bros leans on price and 7 Brew adds food.
Black Rock Coffee Bar tried something simple this year. It kept its shops open later. About 70% of its shops now stay open into the evening, to 8 p.m. or 9 p.m. in many cases, and CEO Mark Davis says the change is now permanent.
The result showed up in its third-quarter numbers. Revenue rose 29.7% to $66.8 million, same-store sales grew 5.8%, and net income came in at $2.7 million, compared with a $16.2 million loss a year earlier. Transactions rose 2.4%.
Compare that with the biggest name in drive-thru coffee growth. A week earlier, Dutch Bros reported company-operated customer visits up just 1.0%, cut its profit outlook, and watched its stock fall more than 16% in off-hours trading. The drive-thru coffee war used to be about who could build the most stands. Now it is also about who can sell a drink at 8:30 p.m.
Advertisement
Later hours brought a younger crowd and more food sales
The evening shift did more than add hours to the schedule. According to Nation's Restaurant News, the later hours pulled in younger customers and lifted food sales, including the cake pops and grilled cheese sandwiches Black Rock added to its menu. Davis described the evening customer plainly: "It's certainly a younger demographic."
The key line for any operator is about money. Davis told analysts the company kept the hours only after they proved out: "When we made the decision to make them permanent, they are definitely profitable."
That order matters. Black Rock tested first and committed second. It also did not flip every shop. Roughly three in ten shops kept their old hours, which suggests the company let local demand decide.
In the earnings release, Davis credited "menu innovation, expanded operating hours, and enhanced loyalty capabilities" for giving customers more reasons to visit through the day. The quarter marked Black Rock's "15th consecutive quarter of positive same-store sales growth."
Dutch Bros is growing on price while visits stall
Dutch Bros is still the bigger, more profitable machine. It ended the quarter with 1,273 shops, $549.8 million in revenue, and $101.1 million in adjusted EBITDA. Revenue grew 29.8%, nearly the same rate as Black Rock.
The problem sits inside the same-store number. Company-operated same shop sales rose 5.4%, but 4.4 points of that came from a higher average ticket. Visits added only 1.0%. Systemwide, visits grew just 0.4%. Over the first nine months, company-operated visits were up 3.6%, so the slowdown is recent.
Management blamed rising gas prices. CEO Christine Barone told analysts, "We did see a heightened level of choppiness in Q3." She also said the company did not see competitive pressure. Investors were less sure. They are watching McDonald's beverage push and 7 Brew, which overlaps with Dutch Bros in four states where each chain has more than 20 shops.
Dutch Bros lowered its 2026 adjusted EBITDA outlook to about $380 million, from $385 million to $390 million, and now expects same shop sales growth of at least 5%. It still plans at least 185 openings this year and about 250 in 2027. It also says it is testing new hot food platforms, but it shared no results.
7 Brew is adding food while it races to 1,000 stands
The fastest grower in the segment is moving on food too. This month 7 Brew added food for the first time: five bakery items at $3 each. The chain has more than 900 stands in 38 states and reached $1.2 billion in sales last year.
Its unit economics explain why rivals are nervous. Restaurant Dive reported that 7 Brew's 2025 average unit volume was over $2.6 million, compared with nearly $2.2 million for Dutch Bros systemwide in the first quarter. Black Rock's average unit volume was $1.296 million.
So the three chains are attacking the same problem from different angles. 7 Brew has huge stand volumes and is adding a food attach. Dutch Bros has scale and is leaning on ticket. Black Rock has smaller shops and is selling more hours.
Advertisement
Black Rock's bet is not risk free
Later hours worked, but Black Rock is still a small company spending hard. Cash fell to $13.6 million at the end of September from $28.4 million at the end of 2025, while it plans $47 million to $48 million in capital spending this year and raised its opening target to 40 stores. Store-level profit margin slipped to 28.9% from 29.6%, and adjusted EBITDA margin dipped to 12.7% from 13.4%.
Wall Street has not rewarded the story yet. Black Rock's stock has lost more than half its value this year. Same-store growth of 5.8% is solid, but it is down from 10.8% a year ago.
What this means for operators
I started as a Starbucks barista and later ran a store. My view: closing time is one of the most underused levers in this business, and most chains set it once and never look again.
- Test hours like a menu item. Black Rock tested later hours, checked profit, then made them permanent. Pick a few stores, run the late shift for a set window, and judge it on contribution margin, not sales alone.
- Do not extend everywhere. About 30% of Black Rock's shops kept their old hours. Trade area, safety, and staffing should decide, store by store.
- Give the night crowd something to eat. Black Rock's evening sales leaned on cake pops and grilled cheese. A late shift with a drinks-only menu leaves money on the counter.
- Read visits and ticket separately. Dutch Bros grew same shop sales 5.4%, but most of that was price. If your comp is mostly ticket, you are not growing your customer base.
- Staff the late shift on purpose. Evening hours often mean a younger team serving a younger crowd. Pair your strongest closer with newer people and build the close checklist before launch.
What to watch
- Dutch Bros fourth quarter: whether visits recover from 0.4% systemwide growth, and whether it shares any results from its hot food tests.
- 7 Brew at 1,000: whether it crosses 1,000 stands by the end of 2026, and how its new $3 bakery items affect ticket.
- Black Rock's 40 openings: whether it hits the raised target with $13.6 million in cash on hand and $21 million of open revolver.
- Copycats: any larger chain that announces extended evening hours across its drive-thrus.
Sources
- Black Rock Coffee Bar, Inc. Reports Third Quarter 2026 Results, Black Rock Coffee Bar via Finviz
- Black Rock Coffee Bar's sales grow, thanks to extended hours, Nation's Restaurant News
- Dutch Bros Inc. Q3 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1), U.S. SEC
- Dutch Bros stock plummets amid competition concerns, Nation's Restaurant News
- 7 Brew adds food to the menu, Nation's Restaurant News
- 7 Brew on pace to reach 1K units in 2026, Restaurant Dive
Advertisement